Skip to main content

Do you want your association to be Walmart?

Earlier this week, I had a small Twitter discussion with Kevin Holland (@associationinc) regarding aggregation as a value proposition.

@associationinc - Deciding your role is to aggregate other people's value is like George Costanza wearing sweatpants. "You're telling the world, 'I give up.'"

@cardcat - Interesting comment about aggregating. Don't you think it is a viable option for a small association who can't afford it?

@associationinc - Nothng wrong with aggregating content as long as you don't perceive it to be your value proposition. There's no real future in it.

@cardcat - Don't think it is THE value proposition, but I think it could be A value to members, a big value.

@associationinc - A big value is something you offer that nobody else can or that u can do better. Aggregating content is easy, there4 unsustainable.

@cardcat - True, it isn't sustainable. But I almost think if you don't act as an aggregator, you risk folks going somewhere else.

@associationinc - And if you don't do your members' taxes, you risk folks going to H&R Block. :) ... Like I said, nothing wrong with it.

@cardcat - Ok, ok. Now you are just getting carried away ;) Yes, nothing wrong with it, but not a long term value prop. Agreed.


That got me thinking more about value in general. Wikipedia talks about value proposition primarily in terms of Benefits and Costs. And many would define value strictly in terms of Benefits and Costs. However, I want to bring up one other word that is key: Expectations.

There is an expected value in a transaction. You expect that Benefits > Costs or you wouldn't do it in the first place. You expect certain benefits for your costs. Although anyone can aggregate data then distribute it, association members tend to expect their association to be the place to go for information (the bigger value proposition). Therefore, you may need to aggregate to meet those expectations. And if someone else aggregates the same info, chances are you are still going to be preferred because of the other things you are doing and your reputation as an industry representative.

If you don't do it, then you may not be filling members' biggest need and expectation, which risks them walking away from the other values that you offer, simply because of convenience. It is why a lot of people go to Walmart. I may have better selection and quality somewhere else, and maybe even price, but at least I can do it in one stop. The question you have to ask yourself is, do you want your association to be Walmart?

**For the record, I am not saying being Walmart is good or bad. It's just one of the many options out there.

Comments

Lindy Dreyer said…
I'm gonna go ahead and say that aggregating content is NOT always so easy, actually--especially as the velocity of publishing continues to accelerate. Can associations do it better? Maybe. Maybe they can do it in a more trusted/vetted environment, too.

Great post. And a great exchange between you and Kevin. I see where you're both coming from.
Kevin said…
I'm just embarrassed that I actually used the phrase "value proposition."
I agree on all parts. Do you choose to be the botique shop and provide trinkets of lovleiness that your members can't find anywhere else or do you try to become the one-stop-shop, Walmart? You have to know what your members want and expect and let that guide your short term strategy (change is inevitable), right? Imagine though your member saying to you, "I belong to your xyz association, but I don't go to you for my information." OUCH and for us right now... no thanks- we'll continue to aggregate and find relevancy in the scads of information for them. Of course we tend to handhold anyway... It's what they expect other than to get more and pay less!

Popular posts from this blog

Apathy vs. Lack of Proper Training

I, like many, worked at a grocery store in high school. First a bagger, then a cashier, then the produce department. Each job required training on how to do it. I usually spent several shifts shadowing someone, then several on my own but with supervision. This method seemed to work just fine. I see it employed places other than the grocery store. Lately, I have been amazed at how poorly grocery bags are packed by store employees. I know that you have to adjust to the bag type, cloth or plastic these days, but I can't tell if the employees are lazy or just didn't get proper training. I even go as far as emptying my cart strategically to try to help - put all the cold stuff together, bread and eggs last so they can go on top, etc. But it doesn't seem to matter. I think there is a fine line between apathy and lack of training, at least trying to identify which situation it is. Anyone have any great ideas for identifing and then fixing either situation?

I have a new job

I am so very excited to announce that as of Oct. 13, I will be the new Executive Director of the Arlington Soccer Association . This is the perfect opportunity for my to combine my work experience and my education (I have a Masters in Sports Administration) with one of my true passions, soccer. I played in college and still play several times a week (which may change since I will most likely be a touch busier.) I still plan on writing this blog. My guess is that you will see the topics change slightly to focus less on membership and more on overall association management areas. Thank you to all who have helped me along the way. I don't want to list names for fear of leaving anyone out, because Lord knows there are a lot. Wish me luck!

10 Thoughts on #ASAE10

Ok, so I could have spelled out the title, but chose the hashtag - #asae10. Supposedly there were over 8,000 tweets with the hashtag, but probably countless more direct messages of messages that left out the hashtag but were conference related. Two years ago, we were using twitter as a backchannel to talk about speakers. Now, over 800 people sent conference related tweets. If you aren't on Twitter, you are already late to the party. Anyway, on with the post... In no particular order, my thoughts on this years ASAE Annual Conference: 1. LA was a good venue. Lots to do. Hotels close by. Only downside was the rooms were a bit of a hike. 2. I missed Sunday because of family obligations. That really put me behind the 8 ball. Since I led a session, that meant I only got to go to 3 true sessions. Sorry, I don't count Joy Behar and the closing session. Although Marshall Goldsmith was good, I probably wouldn't have gone to see that speech as a Learning Lab. 3. Based on #